Christina Aguilera, Tony Lucca Feud: Was the Singer Secretly in Love With Her Co-Star Turned 'Voice' Nemesis?

Posted on May 9th 2012 1:10PM by Sarah Chazan

christina aguilera tony lucca Getty

The big story from "The Voice"s finale last night (May 8) was that Jermaine Paul was crowned this season's big winner. However, throughout the entire season of the show, the even bigger story has been the strange and bitter feud between mentor Christina Aguilera and contestant Tony Lucca. For those unfamiliar with the back story, Christina and Tony starred together as kids on "The Mickey Mouse Club." However, when Lucca came to audition for "The Voice," Aguilera acted as though she didn't recognize him.

But that was just the start of the strangeness between the former costars. As the season progressed, Christina became more and more critical of Tony, calling him out on numerous occasions with downright rude comments. At first, Lucca took the harsh words in stride, but finally snapped back, telling PEOPLE Magazine: "I'm not going to let one person bring me down. Clearly that seems like part of her strategy."

So what gives -- why did Christina seem to have it out for Tony this entire season? According to another former co-star from their "Mickey Mouse Club" days, it may all stem from an unrequited teen crush! Dale Godboldo, who co-starred with Tony and Christina on the show in the '90s, tells TMZ that Aguilera was actually smitten with Lucca back in the day. "Christina was in love with him," reveals Dale. But she wasn't the only one. "Britney was in love with him," added Godboldo, referencing other "MMC" star, Britney Spears.

However, despite the original crush on Aguilera's part, nothing ever came of it, leading Aguilera to hold a grudge against her former object of affection. At least according to Godboldo. "All of this ["Voice"] madness was not brought on by Tony," Dale tells TMZ.

Whether or not Aguilera's bitterness was the cause of the season-long feud, it appears the singer is trying to mend fences with Lucca. During the end of last night's finale, audiences saw Christina whispering sweetly in Tony's ear. "She just wanted to clear the air a bit," Lucca, explained to Us Weekly. "[She] apologize[d] that this became much more of a dramatic thing than she ever intended it. I said to her, 'I hope that we can be cool moving forward. I take pride in the fact that my whole career has been a career of integrity, and sound relationships."

What do you think of this whole Christina/Tony feud? Did the right person win this season of "The Voice"? Tweet us your thoughts @aolmusic.

See Photos of Christina Aguilera Through the Years

See All Music Galleries »

Watch Adam and Christina Duke It Out on "The Voice"

Follow @AOLMusic on Twitter | Like AOL Music on Facebook | Sign Up for Newsletter

Download Christina Aguilera Songs | Buy Christina Aguilera Albums

Filed under: Rumor Mill, Hot Off the Press, Celebrity Feuds

Around The Web:

The Voice Finale -- Why Does Christina Aguilera Hate Tony Lucca?

'The Voice' finalist Tony Lucca breaks silence on Christina Aguilera's ...

The Voice's Christina Aguilera Slams Tony Lucca's "Derogatory ...

'The Voice's' Tony Lucca on Christina Aguilera Criticism: 'I Saw It ...

The Voice Finale: Tony Lucca versus Christina Aguilera - the Feud ...

Christina Aguilera Slams Tony Lucca

Adam Levine & Christina Aguilera Fight After Tony Lucca Performs ...

'The Voice': Was Tony Lucca's '99 Problems' a jab at Christina ...

Add a Comment

Sign in »

141 Comments

Filter by:

Joyanto Das

The show is great though.
Please visit our website: www.jasmineekberg.com

April 30 2013 at 4:41 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

ghgfere

Well, it’s that time of the year again. All of the big design houses are releasing their new designs to the hungry masses, and Gucci Handbags is no exception. Unless you have been stranded on a desert isle for the last thirty years, you have undoubtedly heard of Gucci Outlet. They have been reigning over the fashion world for a great many years, and not totally without warrant. Gucci makes top quality, stylish apparel and accessories for the distinguishing Gucci Handbags On Sale.

September 09 2012 at 11:36 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

The Enlightener

Nah, she didn't actually believe the song was "derogatory toward women", she just wanted to harm his chances because she's a jealous, vindictive bitch. When she claims she didn't intend to harm his chances or his career, it's utterly false. That was totally her intention.

Also Cee Lo and Adam are okay. Blake is an effeminate mangina who picks only female singers based on looks, and never has anything meaningful to say. Christina is a fat, ugly, disgusting bitch.

May 20 2012 at 7:42 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

Lorie

like Arthur replied I am shocked that a student able to earn $9035 in four weeks on the internet. have you seen this web link NuttyRich.com

May 16 2012 at 5:08 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

rern63

The show is great though. As long as ou skip the battle rounds. Boring! Real talent there though. Blows Idol away.

May 15 2012 at 7:41 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

rern63

It is time for a replacement for Christina. And who is dressing her? She needs to realize she is FAT! Wear some clothes that fit. No one wants to see those saggy boobs anymore. Stick to singing Christina. You are no longer hot! Adam, Celo, and Blake are soooo cool. And then there is Christina. Yuck.

May 15 2012 at 7:40 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

merjardin

Sorry about those last 2 lines.... kind of got lost !. I so want CA to be replaced.

May 12 2012 at 5:07 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

merjardin

It was going to be either Jermaine or Chris. The final four were SO worthy. They all have paid their dues.
I am hoping to hear all new options offered, as regards their music careers. Enjoyed this final four very much because of the varied talent they brought to the 'Voice'. Chris was a breath of fresh air. Can see him not only in voice, but also movies and TV. Jermaine, bring that fab voice on, and the best to Tony...may he make Christina eat crow. She has been the most embarrasing altogether for the show, her outfits were NOT 'SEXY'....they were LOW CLASS. and... the four blew her now voice out of the water. Wouldn't shed a tear with her replacement.
outfits (rediculous and guess what.....they all screemed not sexy, but simply put, 'low class'.

May 12 2012 at 5:01 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

emack150

She should had known that his career and reputation was on the line because of her behavior toward him.

She really could had hurt the guy emotionally/professionally because of some past secret crush.

I really hope that she did apologize to the guy and meant it.

May 12 2012 at 2:58 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply

ROE

CA has a fantastic voice......Hands down.....No argument there!!!!! Unfortunately however, her personality lacks the same talent. She seems to have grown quite fond of herself over the years. TOO fond! After watching the Voice for the past two seasons......I've gone from being a CA fan....to now only liking her voice.
She seems more interested in impressing the world with her self....than being a fair judge.
If you payed attention.....Why is it....that she's the ONLY one of the judges that constantly has to go up on stage to give "Hugs" to her "Team". That's more of a "Hey World.....Look at Me" than a sincere hug.
And seriously.......She needs a new Wardrobe Team. It's a family show....not a Cabaret!!!!

May 12 2012 at 11:32 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply