Kevin Winter, Getty Images
Superior Court Judge Thomas Rubinson dismissed counts filed under the law against Paul Raef, who was charged in July with being involved in a high-speed pursuit of Justin Bieber.
The judge cited numerous problems with the 2010 statute, saying it was aimed at newsgathering activities protected by the First Amendment, and lawmakers should have simply increased the penalties for reckless driving rather than targeting celebrity photographers.
Attorneys for Raef argued the law was unconstitutional and wasn't meant to protect the public.
"It's about protecting celebrities," attorney Brad Kasierman said. "This discrimination sets a dangerous precedent."
Prosecutors argued that the law, which seeks to punish those who drive dangerously in pursuit of photos for commercial gain, could apply to people in other professions, not just the media.
"The focus is not the photo. The focus is on the driving," Assistant City Attorney Ann Rosenthal argued.
While the media is granted freedom under the First Amendment, its latitude to gather news is not unlimited, Rosenthal argued.
"This activity has been found to be particularly dangerous," she said of chases involving paparazzi.
Raef still faces traditional reckless driving counts and has not yet entered a plea,
Prosecutors claim he chased Bieber at more than 80 mph and forced other motorists to avoid collisions while trying to get shots of the teen heartthrob on a Los Angeles freeway.
The chase prompted several 911 calls from scared motorists and led to Bieber being pulled over.
Rubinson cited hypothetical examples in which wedding photographers or even those rushing to do a portrait shoot with a celebrity could face additional penalties if charged under the new statute.
Rosenthal also argued that the judge should look at factors specific to Raef's case, not hypothetical scenarios.
Kaiserman said the ruling only applies to Raef's case but could lead to the law being struck down if prosecutors appeal.
Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP news report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press. Active hyperlinks have been inserted by AOL.
Check Out Our Exclusive Justin Bieber Photos
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Justin Bieber's Exclusive Shoot With AOL Music
- Celebrity Photobombs
- Peek-a-Boo Sheryl Crow, We See You! (Even if Justin Bieber Didn't.)
- This Guy Is SO Not Impressed by Rihanna and Katy Perry.
- Kelly Osbourne and Neon Hitch's Photo-Op Is Crashed by an Over-Enthused Lurker.
- Demi Lovato's Little Sis Madison Perhaps Isn't the Biggest Britney Fan.
- Paul Stanley, Sir Elton John and Erin Sutton Get Creeped on.
- Katy Perry Is Unaware That Glen Campbell Is Having a Psychic Moment Behind Her.
- Diddy REALLY Wanted to Be in This Shot With Muhammad Ali and Will Smith.
- This Passerby Can't Resist Sharing the Spotlight With Rihanna.
- Kim Kardashian and Nicki Minaj Try to Box Out a Fellow BET Awards Attendee.
- Celebrities Who Married Young - Barely Legal Brides!
- LeAnn Rimes Was a Bride at 19
- Avril Lavigne Was 21 When She Walked Down the Aisle
- Hilary Duff Said 'I Do' at 22
- Kevin Jonas Proposed at 21, Married at 22
- For Hanson, Marrying Young Runs in the Family
- Kate Hudson Married at 21 After Dating Just a Year
- Solange Got Married in a Hurry
- Celebrity Makeup Makeovers
- Kelly Osbourne
- Christina Aguilera
- Nicki Minaj
- Ke$ha
- Taylor Momsen
- Adele
- Lily Allen
Watch "Justin Bieber Assaults More Paparazzi In London"
Sila
Kimberly
Tim McGraw's 'Superstar Summer Night' Special to Air May 19
Jennifer Hudson Performs 'Inseparable' With 'American Idol' Winner Candice Glover
Tim McGraw Stops Atlanta Show to Help Ailing Fan
Taylor Swift Dominates at 2013 Billboard Music Awards
Mario Announces Nicki Minaj Collaboration, 'Somebody Else'
Justin Bieber BOOED While Accepting Award
Carrie Underwood Says She's 'Queen of Awkward' in Marie Claire Interview
PHOTOS:Eva Longoria's Almost Wardrobe Malfunction At Cannes
Kellie Pickler Advances to 'Dancing With the Stars' Finals
Tornadoes Strike Oklahoma
Taylor Swift Admired George Jones' Passion for Performing
Student Expelled, Charged With Felonies For Same-Sex Relationship
Stone Temple Pilots Tap Linkin Park's Chester Bennington as New Singer
15 Incredible Cat Photobombs
Carrie Underwood 'Goats' Hunter Hayes With Blown Away Tour Prank
LOOK: Dolphins Make Rare Underwater Find
PHOTOS: Stars Shine On The 2013 Billboard Music Awards Red Carpet
OUCH: Singer Jumps, Lands On Fan's Neck
PHOTOS: Miley Cyrus Decides To Wear Pants To The 2013 Billboard Music Awards
Mom Thought Family Was Being Stalked By 'Demonic Presences': Cops
Stefon Marries Anderson Cooper In Final Show
Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson Reportedly Split
LOOK: National Geographic's Stunning Photo Contest
Radio Host Makes Shocking Claim About Shooting Hillary Clinton
Powerball Jackpot Winning Ticket Purchased In Florida
All The Pics: Jessica Ennis Marries Andy Hill
Suspected PayPal Hackers Seek Deal To Stay Out Of Prison
Obama Approval Rating Not Hurt By Scandals
How Kidnapping Suspect Passes Time Behind Bars
Police Investigate Student Shooting Death
2 Comments